You know what's intense? The envelope method.
I totally understand what turned me off of this budgeting tool in the past. Being happily obsessed with debt payment, any sum of money has always cheerfully been shunted into that category of "spending." Be it $12 or $2,000, I'd make that payment, consequences be damned.
Which is one of the reasons my teeth still suck, among other things. Because, no matter the adulation received for making debt payment, you take from every other element of your life when you focus exclusively on That One Thing.
The envelope method makes this impossible to ignore.
This is my process and resulting thoughts so far:
As previously mentioned, Darling and I used years of data to work out how much, on average, we spend in every category. We happen to have 13 categories. You may have more, you might have fewer. I am opposed to the concept of a "misc." category for numerous reasons, but, again, it took years of analysis to happen upon our specific sets of patterns and behaviors. I didn't just sit down and guess at any of this. Nor did I "project" at all, assuming that our current lifestyle or eventual lifestyle would result to any increase or decrease in spending or income. I've watched our income jump from $0 a month to $4,000 a month and back. Core expenses stay pretty constant.
I converted those number to percentages of income (again, average income, not current). So I now know that we typically dedicate 1% of our income to clothing, 3% to the phone, and 37% to rent.
That was the easy part. I then relaxed for a couple of weeks and let the holidays happen. Yesterday Darling and I both got paid. I took those checks and money left over from last year. My first realization is that we had enough to pay rent and catch up on our back rent! Hurray!
In the past I would have gone to the bank, cut the check, and - more or less happy with the idea that "we're on the right track," gone out to eat, over-spent, over-drafted, etc. This time I sat down and sorted all of that money into the envelopes. 1% into the hygiene envelope, 2% into fees and fines, and so on...
Okay. Now, if we have $1,700, and I want to write a check to the house for $1,600, and there's only $600 in the "rent" envelope, and only $200 in the "debt" envelope, there's $800 to borrow from other envelopes.
Huh.
You guys would have laughed to see me. I was shuffling through my envelopes with insane determination, as though I was going to squeeze $800 out of our clothing and office supplies budget. Well, obviously I can't empty out the transportation or travel budget....Keep in mind that none of this was cash floating around, but index cards noting amounts (we will be working with cash, but the money is still in check form as I write). Still. It was a bit mad.
Finally, I settled with $7 in the hygiene envelope (we need toothpaste and shaving cream), and $10 in the entertainment envelope. Everything else has an index card that says, "$0, debt owes you $x.
Now, with the amount of attention I pay to money one might imagine this wouldn't have been such a breakthrough. But it really,
really is. It looked like I had a lot of money. And paying most of it to debt made me feel like I deserved a reward. I was skipping the part where paying my money to debt meant no money for a reward...or to meet other needs, like gas.
I'm still catching up on rent, though.